Click on any topic below to OPEN/CLOSE once the page has finished loading:or choose + Open All Topics or - Close All Topics
The Union Policy at the War's Outset: Return Slaves to Their Masters
The Use of Slaves to Support the Southern Military Effort
The "Fort Monroe Doctrine" Declares Slaves "Contrabands of War"
"Stampede Among the Negroes in Virginia,"
|
A Soldier
at Fort Monroe: |
| FORTRESS MONROE, JUNE 7, 1861
To the Editor of The Boston Journal: My mind perpetually recurs, as to a subject of constantly augmenting interest to the everlasting Ethiopian. From the veteran of eighty-five--the oldest of the corps--the the ebony youth who minds the horses at the door, every member of the Virginia Brigade is a study. "What sort of a man is your master?" asked an officer of the negro on board the little sloop brought in from James River by the Harriet Lane yesterday. "Ver bad man, sah," was the reply; "dref'l secessh--better hang him, sah, 'fore he do mischief." One who has thus far proved himself singularly useful in every service in which he has been employed, is most decidedly a character. Four years he has been a "woods nigger," that is to say, having been soundly beaten by his master once, he declared he would endure that sort of thing but once more; being badly beaten again and pickled moreover, he dissolved his connection with is master and took to the woods. Since that time he has defied all the white men in the Elizabeth City to catch him. Once he was caught and jailed, but not fancying jail life, he vanished one day. Two of the fellows came to his cell; one he knocked senseless, and while the other carried the wounded away, he escaped. He is now making himself generally useful. He can brush a coat, black boots, take charge of a wardrobe, drive hard bargains with the sutler, explain the geography of the country for fifty miles around, tell at any time just where the enemy is posted and in what force, and withall--as I am informed by his present possessor--can concoct every sort of beverage known in the Virginia vernacular, with consummate skill. If such a piece of property isn't contraband, what is? *** Yours respectfully, TIMOTHY GORDON |
![]() |
|
Despite Lincoln's concern that freeing slaves would encourage border states to join the confederacy, Congress supported Butler's move by passing the the first Confiscation Act in August of 1861. That act authorized Union forces to seize rebel property and freed slaves who had fought or labored on behalf of the confederate army from further obligations to their masters. The Second Confiscation Act, passed on July17, 1862 expanded the rights outlined in the first. It stipulated:
That all slaves of persons who shall hereafter be engaged in rebellion against the government of the United States, or who shall in any way give aid or comfort thereto, escaping from such persons and taking refuge within the lines of the army; and all slaves captured from such persons or deserted by them and coming under the control of the government of the United States; and all slaves of such persons found on [or] being within any place occupied by rebel forces and afterwards occupied by the forces of the United States, shall be deemed captives of war, and shall be forever free of their servitude, and not again held as slaves.
In addition to authorizing the president "to make provision for the transportation, colonization, and settlement, in some tropical country beyond the limits of the United States, of such persons of the African race, made free by the provisions of this act, as may be willing to emigrate" the Second Confiscation Act also authorized him "employ as many persons of African descent as be may deem necessary and proper for the suppression of this rebellion."
Contraband Policy as the Origins of a "Freedman's Bureau" |
It was at this point, probably, where the first idea of a “Freedman’s Bureau” took its origin. Orders of the government prohibited the expulsion of the negroes from the protection of the army, when they came in voluntarily. Humanity forbade allowing them to starve. With such an army of them, of all ages and both sexes, as had congregated about Grand Junction, amounting to many thousands, it was impossible to advance. There was no special authority for feeding them unless they were employed as teamsters, cooks and pioneers with the army; but only able-bodied young men were suitable for such work. This labor would support but a very limited percentage of them. The plantations were all deserted; the cotton and corn were ripe: men, women and children above ten years of age could be employed in saving these crops. To do this work with contrabands, or to have it done, organization under a competent chief was necessary. On inquiring for such a man Chaplain Eaton, now and for many years the very able United States Commissioner of Education, was suggested. He proved as efficient in that field as he has since done in his present one. I gave him all the assistants and guards he called for. We together fixed the prices to be paid for the negro labor, whether rendered to the government or to individuals. The cotton was to be picked from abandoned plantations, the laborers to receive the stipulated price (my recollection is twelve and a half cents per pound for picking and ginning) from the quartermaster, he shipping the cotton north to be sold for the benefit of the government. Citizens remaining on their plantations were allowed the privilege of having their crops saved by freedmen on the same terms. At once the freedmen became self-sustaining. The money was not paid to them directly, but was expended judiciously and for their benefit. They gave me no trouble afterwards. Later the freedmen were engaged in cutting wood along the Mississippi River to supply the large number of steamers on that stream. A good price was paid for chopping wood used for the supply of government steamers (steamers chartered and which the government had to supply with fuel). Those supplying their own fuel paid a much higher price. In this way a fund was created not only sufficient to feed and clothe all, old and young, male and female, but to build them comfortable cabins, hospitals for the sick, and to supply them with many comforts they had never known before. --Ulysses S. Grant, "Chapter 30," Personal Memoirs, 1885–86 |
Debate raged in the North about the propriety of Butler's actions. The fact that this initiative would provide fresh support for Union military efforts impressed some. As one newspaper reported:Gen. Butler has introduced a new plough into Virginia. It is a LEGAL plough; and it turns over slavery in that state as handsomely as ever one of Knox's ploughs turned over a field of green sward. "Articles contraband of war," is the name he gives to slaves that come into his camp or into the possession of our troops. Several hundred of the "articles" have run into Fortress Monroe, and are rendering good service; the administration having advised Gen. Butler to keep an account, for the present, of the amount of their labor and of the cost of their keeping. If the "articles" should turn out to be men, it will be very proper for the government to compensate them for the labor they perform; and wherever there is an army, there must necessarily be a great amount of work to be done.
--"General Butler's Plough," The (Worcester) Palladium, June 5, 1861
Moreover, by calling the former slaves “contrabands of war” rather than “freemen,” Butler avoided inflaming the concerns of some of those Northerners who continued to oppose emancipation. An article in Frank Leslie's Illustrated Newspaper explained:
The promptness and sagacity of General Butler have increased the dilemma of the Secessionists to a remarkable degree, since it is at once equally hostile to both Abolitionism and Secession. By declaring slaves as contrabands of war, he recognizes them as property, and, consequently as liable to capture.
--"Negroes Taking Refuge at Fort Monroe," Frank Leslie's Illustrated Newspaper, June 8, 1861, 55
Slaves had been considered "property" rather than human beings, and contrabands would have the same status. Thus, they would experience no change in their legal standing, instead, they would only exchange one "master" for another. Under Butler's directive, it would be the federal government rather than the slaveowner who controlled and benefited from their labor.
Evolving Northern Responses to Butler, the War, & Slavery |
The contraband notion was adopted by Congress in the Act of July 6th, which confiscates slaves used in aiding the Insurrection. There is often great virtue in such technical phrases in shaping public opinion. They commend practical action to a class of minds little developed in the direction of the sentiments, which would be repelled by formulas of a broader and nobler import. The venerable gentleman, who wears gold spectacles and reads a conservative daily, prefers confiscation to emancipation. He is reluctant to have slaves declared freemen, but has no objection to their being declared contrabands. His whole nature rises in insurrection when Beecher preaches in a sermon that a thing ought to be done because it is a duty, but he yields gracefully when Butler issues an order commanding it to be done because it is a military necessity. --from Edward L. Pierce's"The Contrabands at Fortress Monroe," Atlantic Monthly, November 1861, pp. 626-640FUGITIVE SLAVES.—The House of Representatives have passed a bill, by a vote of 83 to 42, prohibiting officers in the army and navy of the United States from arresting fugitive slaves for the purpose of returning them to slavery, under penalty of dismissal from the service. -- Frank Leslie’s Illustrated Newspaper, March 15, 1862, 259.THEATRICAL AND MUSICAL A singular and perhaps a significant feature of theatricals in New York, is the revival of the Anti-Slavery drama, “Uncle Tom’s Cabin;” it is now played at four places of amusement in this city, and draws crowded houses in all. The events of the past year have evidently not added to the popular admiration for the system of human bondage. -- Frank Leslie’s Illustrated Newspaper, March 15, 1862, 275 |
![]() |
|
The South Threatens Butler with Poison and the Knife |
ADVOCATING ASSSASSINATION.—The brutalizing effect of the rebellion on its apostles and upholders is strongly evinced in open advocacy of poisoning and assassination. The Jacksonville Mississippian, the State paper of Davis’s own State, advocates the raising of a purse of $10,000 for the head of Gen. Butler, whom it characterizes as a “brutal, beastly and sanguinary savage,” whose life “should be taken by any means whatsoever.” The Charleston Mercury goes on in the same strain. “Let no quarter to Butler be the sworn resolve of every Southern man.” It adds, “If he venture not upon the field of battle, let poison or the knife do its secret but deadly work.” And these are the people who ask to be admitted into the brotherhood of civilized nations! —Frank Leslie’s Illustrated Newspaper, July 5, 1862, 211 |
|
|
![]() |
|
![]() |
|
A Letter from a Union Soldier Describing Contrabands Published in a Northern Paper |
|---|
On the 2st inst., one of our sentinels thought he heard a cry for help floating down from far up the river: 'come and get us!" was the rude, faint voice that came from more than two miles across the water from an island of mud and rank grass. From the ramparts of the fort we discovered an object which proved to be a pole holding up a towel raised by the suffering wanderers. A boat was dispatched which brought in three besmeared starving colored men. These reported more men and three women in a similar situation further up the river. A second boat was sent out, which after hours of search, venturing close to the enemy's lines, rescued the periled and destitute company. These refugees were a spectacle--almost naked, the women having only little miserable skirts that reached to their knees, besmeared with mud, as one said,, "boggy as de bog eself,' famished and almost entirely exhausted. For nine weary days and fearful nights they had been feeling their perilous way from the slave pens, twelve miles beyond Savannah, through the rebel bivouacs and lines, wading through swamps, skulking through forests, and swimming three rivers, the women clinging to the necks of the men, floundering across the mud islands, as they said, "like de alligators," till they discovered the dear tars and stripes floating over fort Pulaski. The original party consisted of twelve; four gave out on the way. The famished but persevering eight were consuming their last morsel of food when they descried our garrison flag. One of them said," when I seed that flag, it fill me right up." What a compliment from the human soul to our standard! How unspeakably sweet is the thought of liberty! Tell us not that the slave is indifferent to freedom. But miles of distance and the swift flowing Savannah still divided them from help and safety. The wind baffled their uplifted voices. Another night of hunger, nakedness, and peril, was before them on their island of mud, where they mired to their waists. Before the sun went down they saw a steamer visit the fort, and hoping they had been heard, looked longingly for her to come up the river after them, but when they saw her leave the fort and disappear from view on her way towards Port Royal, their hearts egan to fail them: one remarked, "when I seed de steamboat go way, my heart go down to de bottom of my foot." But the calm of the following morning allowed their cry of freedom to reach our ears and their rude stick an little towel attracted our eyes. Pitiable yet unutterably happy creatures they were when they reached our garrison. One moment's view of them and interview with them would have melted the most obdurate of "copperheads." They had been working for the confederate government and a little corn bread daily was their whole compensation. As we handed to one of them a loaf of bread, he ejaculated, "Gorry, Massa, dat be work two or free dollar in Sawannna." In almost every sentence they would exclaim, "Tank the Lord, we get away."--Letter from Fort Pulaski --"Touching Story of Contrabands," The Worcester Daily Spy, April 8, 1864 |
An American Antiquarian
Society Online Exhibition
Curated by Lucia Z. Knoles, Professor of English, Assumption College